X vs X

| No Comments
Previously published at The Iterate (defunct)

I've always been partial to the second diagram here, although I think Shane's consideration in the comments should be remembered.

The diagram is a simplification (and I generally dislike overly-complex diagrams), meant to show relationships between each G and the grade before it and after it when those come into conflict.

E.g., in a 2GW vs 1GW conflict, the 2GW force has positional/proactive advantages over the 1GW force, and the 1GW force is kinetically driven, or reactive, to what the 2GW force does. But in a 3GW vs 2GW conflict, the 3GW has the positional/proactive advantage whereas the 2GW is kinetically driven and reactive to the 3GW force.

The added fillip to this version of the diagram, of separating w/ greater space the two forces with every "up-grade" to the conflict, was intended to suggest not only a) the greater dispersal of kinetics within the conflict, but also possibly b) the greater time frames involved in proaction/reaction.  On the last, I think that whether the diagram successfully shows anything related to time frames may be debatable.

Also, I would note: my use of the term generation -- this is an older post, before "gradient" began to be used -- and the fact that, whatever utility exists in talking of grades or gradients, I still have more interest in considering linear developments and relationships between each "G" than some others currently writing about 5GW.

And: I have never answered, but have often wondered, what precisely the G relationships would be between gradients further apart than +/- 1.  E.g., 5GW vs 3GW or 4GW vs 1GW.  I think we have  had some too-brief statements of principle concerning such conflicts but I am not entirely satisfied with them. 
(Note: This post originally referred to a previous post, X vs X: Follow-up and Query.)

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Curtis Gale Weeks published on August 27, 2009 2:59 PM.

On "One Hand Clapping" was the previous entry in this blog.

Engaging Emergence is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Categories

Pages

OpenID accepted here Learn more about OpenID
Powered by Movable Type 5.01